Sunday, May 30, 2004

To tell or not to tell?

I wrote an article called Malaysian men are well-mannered which was published in “Your say” of Star Mag, The Sunday Star newspapers on 18 April 2004. I can’t believe the kind of responses it evokes. I accidentally discovered that it also started an 11-page provocative and lively discussion in the Forum portal of the Buysell website. The participants were skeptical that Malaysian men are well-mannered. They wondered if I was a gorgeous woman LOL. They questioned if our schools still teach manners. This discussion clearly shows that Malaysians themselves believe in the “Ugly Malaysian” maxim.
This brings me to the issue at hand. As a writer it’s always a dilemma deciding if we should write the whole truth, nothing but the truth. I’ve learnt that people, by nature that they possess feelings, cannot accept the truth but when the truth is embellished with some untruth they’ll willingly accept it as the truth. To a writer there’s nothing controversial because we are just stating the truth but society deems any truth as controversial because it hurts. I wrote that Malaysian men are well-mannered because in my experience it’s the truth. I was probably lucky to have met only the well-mannered ones.
When a writer writes what he deems to be the truth he’ll be persecuted because society finds it hard to swallow the truth. Rushdie was condemned when his book The Satanic Verses came out because society could not accept his views of a certain religion. To a writer there’s nothing controversial about anything written because if a writer honestly believes that what he is writing is the truth then he can’t be faulted. If a writer writes a falsehood on purpose to achieve fame, notoriety and profits I guess he is being irresponsible and untrue to his calling.
Sometimes, the most difficult question for a writer to answer is to tell or not to tell. To maintain his integrity I’m afraid the truth must be told, even if it hurts. Either that or not write at all, if the writer is worried that the truth might harm somebody or himself, like in the case of Rushdie. A writer must therefore possess courage in order to tell the truth and then to be able to withstand the attacks. Anything that touches on the human emotions can be turned into a controversy. So the question is to tell or not to tell! Any takers?

6 Comments:

At 5:35 AM, June 22, 2005, Anonymous Anonymous said...

to tell.Afterall,it's what the writer feels and thinks.People must learn to accept that although it evokes lots of controversy

 
At 8:35 AM, June 23, 2005, Blogger TheKampungOwl said...

i agree whole-heartedly with you LOL so i always tell.however,shallow people don't understand what true writng is all about.they cry and curse me hah!i've created quite a controversy in 2002 when i wrote the truth.i'll always cling on to the writer's integrity.

 
At 5:01 AM, June 24, 2005, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Maybe the question should be "How to tell?" rather than "To tell or not to tell"...

 
At 7:04 PM, June 24, 2005, Anonymous Anonymous said...

tell or not to tell doesnt mean its bothering u. it is just a thing that needs bravery to do it and nothing is just controlling you in something and you just need to be yourself.

 
At 8:46 AM, June 26, 2005, Blogger TheKampungOwl said...

thinker is right.the qn should be "How to tell?" but we still must tell it as it is,no shying away from the truth and no euphemisms to lessen the pain LOL

 
At 10:04 AM, July 17, 2005, Blogger TheKampungOwl said...

i'm taking up thta challenge and will be writing that racist piece as soon as i've the time but meanwhile allow me to finish writing a report and setting some exam question papers. just thinking of having that piece printed in the StarMag pullout of the Sunday Star sets my heart a- racing LOL

 

Post a Comment

<< Home